Who’s On Third?

Yoohoo! Houston! It’s me, Bethany!

Yep, we have a problem.

There’s a teenager in the house.

Waldorf is now 13.

And because, overwhelmingly, the response to an article I wrote for WhatToExpect.com was “Read Masterminds and Wingman by Rosalind Wiseman,” I bought the book and have been reading it.

I think I’m not supposed to ask my teenage son direct questions. At least not about school the minute he gets into the car. On that I’m fairly clear.

I’m not sure if the same applies when I’m picking him up from a social event.

Which recently happened.

And I haven’t read all of Masterminds and Wingmen, so proceed with one eye opened. And keep the other eye on your delicious toddler who is right now pulling on your pant leg and sucking on zwieback while you try to read. Know that one day, this too will be your life.


“So, your brother had a really fun time at his party.  He told me he played violent video games.” I start with this nugget as soon as the host closes the door behind us.

See what I did there? I am talking to him, but not about him. And I’m speaking his language. The language of video games. Also, I don’t know if this is right or wrong. But we’re in it together now, so just roll with me.  

“Violent video games? Hmm. I’ll have to get to the bottom of that,” he replies.

“It’s disturbing to me, but he seemed excited about it.” Because duh. Violent video games are fucking disturbing.  

We cross the quiet street side by side and he slides into the passenger seat of my car. At 5’8”, Waldorf is three inches taller than I am. Unless we drive somewhere as a family, he has permanently staked his claim to shotgun until he graduates to the driver’s seat.

Am I supposed to ask him now if he had fun? Or am I not supposed to ask him? Is that question off limits altogether? Is it school I’m not supposed to ask him about or is it everything?

Wait, am I even allowed to talk?

I haven’t read that far in the book yet.

You see, I want to read the entire book, but FOUR KIDS.

He breaks the silence with, “Speaking of violence, I almost got violent.”

Oh, great. More violence. “Really? In a video game?”

“No. At the party,” he says matter-of-factly.

Well, now I’m going to make some extra turns and go home the long way. Because what the hell is this?

“Oh, dear.” Oof, that’s not the right thing to say. “What happened?”

“I’ll tell you what happened. One of my friends was acting…out of control,” he is casual, but out of the corner of my eye, I notice he is flexing and unflexing his fingers as he speaks.

“Define ‘out of control’,” I say in an award winning attempt to keep the alarm out of my voice. Despite the fact that my throat is closing.

“Like a dog without a leash,” he replies without hesitation.

“Wow,” is all I can manage.

Because Wow

A. We don’t have a dog.

B.That’s quite a metaphor for this particular boy.

“Exactly,” he says as though he has illustrated his point clearly. Game Over, Mom. Discussion Closed, lady.

“Well, some dogs are OK without leashes. Like Josephine who walks across the school playground? But other dogs always need to be on a leash,” I point out.

I can’t see him in the dark, but I don’t need to to know that he is rolling his eyes as he turns to address my profile, “Josephine, if you remember correctly, attacked another dog on the playground last year. You saw it with your own eyes. Which proves my point.”

“What point is that?” I ask.


“Waldorf? Which point?”

“My. Point. That all dogs need leashes.” Again, duh.

I am so confused. Was there a dog at the party? Two dogs? Was his friend acting like a dog towards the girls? Pantomiming a four legged animal? Or acting like a metaphorical dog in a sexual manner?

“So, what does that mean in human terms? Being a dog without a leash?” I ask.

“You know what it means,” he fires back.

“Does it mean he was disrespectful? Was he inappropriate? Was he destructive in someone else’s home?”

“I don’t have time for specifics. You know what it means,” he snaps.

“I do?”

I do??




What Would Rosalind Wiseman Do?

“What do you think I think it means?” I ask. It sounds like something a psychiatrist might say. I don’t know whether that’s a stroke of genius or the kiss of death. But it’s all I have.

“Oh, it means what you think it means,” he says.


“What do you think it means?” Again with the shrink speak.

“What I think is different from what you think. But in this case, we’re both right,” he shrugs.

“We are?”

We are????

“Yes,” he crosses his arms and looks out the window.

I’m so confused. I’m so confused! Should I call the parents who just hosted my son and see if their dog is OK? Did someone let their dog out without a leash?

He interrupts my frantic thoughts, “Listen, when someone is out of control, there is only one thing that can happen, and you know what it is.”

“I do?”


“Can you give me a hint? Because I feel really tired in my brain and I don’t know the one thing that can happen when someone is out of control.” Help me. For the love of god, help me.

“All you need to know is I handled it,” he replies.

You handled it?” I ask.

“That’s what I said.”

“Did you handle it properly?” I ask.

“I know how to handle these things. I handle them all the time. It falls on me. And so…I do it.”

Don't worry, Ma. I handled it.

Don’t worry, Ma. I handled it.

Now the moment I publish this, I’m going to get a barrage of texts from my Mom friends. “Spill it. Who is the dog without a leash? You’d tell me if it were my son, right?”

Who it was and what happened are inconsequential.

There is a much bigger issue here.


We had a serious conversation. It appeared he felt that he needed to get it off his chest. And I love that he knew he could tell me.

But I am so very confused.


Later that night, after we send Waldorf to bed, B&B catches me digging through the bottom of a Lucky Charms cereal box.

“You don’t eat that cereal,” he says.

“I’m not eating the cereal. I’m looking for the secret decoder ring at the bottom.”

I relay the exchange I had in the car to my husband.

He laughs and remarks, “Good for him. Handling it.”

OMFG. Not him too.

“You’re not helping me. What does that mean?” I ask.

He shrugs, “I don’t know. Did he duct tape the dude to a chair or something? Pull him aside and tell him he was acting like a dick?”

I wave my hands frantically in front of me, “I don’t know! I need you to get to the bottom of it. I am so confused. He sounded like Luca fucking Brasi in the passenger seat of my car! But I’m not Don Corleone. I’M KAY!”

He smiles, “He’s figuring it out. Maybe that’s all you need to know. He had a conflict and he feels like he resolved it on his own. It’s OK for you to be Kay. Plus Luca Brasi is the enforcer. Which is bad-ass.”


It’s not OK.

Because Kay is the single most annoying character in The Godfather.

Even worse, Luca Brasi sleeps with the fishes.

The good news is, I heard Rosalind Wiseman speak at my kids’ school last night. And she was fantastic!  I’m going to see if I can get a hold of her email address. Then I’ll ask her to do me a solid and clear this mess up.

In the meantime, I’ll keep reading.

Also, I’ve moved on to Cracker Jack boxes.

Because I could really use that decoder ring.


16 thoughts on “Who’s On Third?

  1. GREAT! When YOU figure it out, please feel free to share with the class. But don’t share it in words that will require me to find my own decoder ring. Please share it in small, easy to understand words, and for the love of Pete, don’t say “Oh YOU know what it means” because I can assure you, I most certainly DON’T.

    I’m glad he felt comfortable enough to open up to you, er, share with you, er, totally confuse you.

  2. Jesus, Mary and Joseph, I don’t look forward to this, but I can see it approaching. The First Born is now 11 and the “dragging information out of him – without it seeming like I am dragging information out of him” has already started. AND. I. HATE. IT.

    Godspeed, my friend. And Much Love!

    • How is he 11??? You are right up against it. It’s knocking on the door as we type. This book is important I think. Waldorf has opened up to me about things on his own time since I’ve stopped hitting him with question after question once he enters the car at the end of the day. I generally say, “Hi, hon,” turn on the radio and tell the other boys to stop arguing or I’ll pull over until they do.

  3. Loved your article, Bethany. I’m impressed by your handling of the conversation with your 13-year-old. You were very respectful of his privacy and his feelings. Isn’t that what it’s all about? Treating kids the way you’d like to be treated?

    • Thanks, Carolyn! I think that’s what it’s about, but it’s hard to keep that in perspective when they go out into the world and WE DON’T KNOW WHAT THEY’RE DOING! I need an emoji with a nervous face right here.

  4. The best talks happen while driving because the car offers teenagers a safe place to spill their guts without other ears around. When my boys were upset we would go for long drives and they felt safe because I couldn’t look at them all the time, prying information out of them by looking into their eyes. As far as getting the whole story – at least you got a story. You don’t need a decoder ring; you need a seat belt – it is going to be a long, bumpy joy and clenched jaw ride.

  5. At least he “handled it.” And it sounds like you’ve got a good one there if he’s steering clear of the ones who are out of control, but I know what you mean. My daughter is 13 & mums the word. I read all these things about how to ask things indirectly. Like you can’t ask about their, day but you can say, “What was one good thing and 1 bad thing that happened today,” as if my kids don’t know how to side step that one. Good thing was when school let out. Bad thing was having to good to school.

    • Yes, and my oldest now answers those indirect questions with sarcasm. “What was one bad thing that happened at school?” “Poop.” “What was something unexpected that happened at school?” “Poop.” Meanwhile, my oldest may be out of control too. I’m still confused. Thanks for reading!

    • Masterminds and Wingmen. Don’t bother with the library. You need to own it. Dog-ear that puppy. Also, I’m your guinea pig. So there’s that.

  6. WOW! I am doomed! Lauren is 9 and is usually pretty good with telling me stuff, but not always. She doesn’t explains stuff well though. I see the next 9 years are going to be VERY LOOOOOOONG!

    But on a side note, it sounds like you and B&B are raising some very respectful and responsible young men which doesn’t surprise me in the least knowing you both. You should be very proud of yourself!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *